Don’t Let Your Marketing Get Lost in the Numbers

by | Dec 4, 2022 | Marketing

Measuring marketing isn’t easy, and there are plenty of challenges you’ll face when attempting to measure the effectiveness of marketing strategies and tactics.

Some of the biggest challenges include:

  • The difficulty of isolating the impact of marketing efforts: Marketing campaigns often operate alongside other factors that can influence a business’s performance, such as changes in the economy or shifts in consumer behavior. This can make it difficult to accurately measure the impact of marketing efforts on a business’s performance.
  • The lag time between marketing efforts and their impact: Marketing campaigns often take time to generate results, and it can be difficult to accurately measure the impact of a campaign in the short term. This can make it challenging to determine whether a marketing campaign is effective.
  • The complexity of modern marketing: Modern marketing involves a wide range of tactics and channels, from traditional advertising to social media marketing and content marketing. This complexity can make it difficult to measure the effectiveness of individual tactics and campaigns accurately.
  • The subjectivity of marketing metrics: Many traditional metrics used to measure the effectiveness of marketing efforts, such as click-through rates and conversion rates, are based on subjective criteria. This can make it difficult to accurately compare the performance of different marketing campaigns.

Many people question the value of fundamental marketing strategies and tactics because they might not produce clear, measurable, numeric results that show up easily in a spreadsheet. They believe  marketing campaigns should be able to immediately demonstrate increased sales or other tangible benefits. If a marketing campaign can’t produce quick, quantifiable results, many write the effort off as the campaign simply “not working”—when that couldn’t be further from the truth.

Companies can’t survive on quantitative data alone

Quantitative data, such as metrics like click-through rates and conversion rates, can provide valuable insights into the performance of a marketing campaign. These metrics can help businesses track the success of their marketing efforts and make informed decisions about how to allocate their marketing budgets. However, it is important to remember that these metrics do not tell the whole story of a marketing campaign’s results.

One of the limitations of relying solely on quantitative data to evaluate the effectiveness of marketing is that it can only provide a limited view of a campaign’s impact. For example, metrics like click-through rates and conversion rates only measure a specific aspect of a marketing campaign’s performance, such as the number of people who engage with an advertisement or the number of people who make a purchase after being exposed to marketing materials. These metrics may not accurately capture the full range of benefits that marketing can provide, such as increased brand awareness or improved customer satisfaction.

Quantitative data may not accurately reflect the long-term impact of a marketing campaign. Many marketing efforts take time to generate results, and it can be difficult to accurately measure the impact of a campaign in the short term. This means that relying solely on quantitative data to evaluate the effectiveness of a marketing campaign may not provide a complete picture of its results.

The subjectivity of many marketing metrics can make it difficult to accurately compare the performance of different marketing campaigns. For example, different marketing tactics may have different objectives and may be aimed at different audiences, which can make it difficult to compare the performance of these tactics using a single metric. This can make it challenging to determine which tactics are the most effective and where to allocate marketing resources.

While quantitative data can provide valuable insights into the performance of marketing campaigns, it is important to remember that it does not tell the whole story of a campaign’s results. Relying solely on quantitative data to evaluate the effectiveness of marketing can be misleading and may not provide a complete picture of a campaign’s impact. In order to fully understand the value of marketing, businesses need to consider a wider range of metrics and factors, including both quantitative and qualitative data.

Just because you don’t see the results doesn’t mean they’re not happening

In marketing, just because you don’t see the results of a campaign doesn’t mean they’re not happening. This is because the impact of marketing efforts can often be difficult to measure and may not be immediately apparent.

For example, a marketing campaign may be aimed at increasing brand awareness or improving customer satisfaction, rather than generating immediate sales. In these cases, the results of the campaign may not be immediately visible, but they can still have a significant impact on a business’s performance over time.

Additionally, the impact of a marketing campaign may take time to become apparent. Marketing efforts often require time to generate results, and it can be difficult to accurately measure the impact of a campaign in the short term. As a result, the results of a marketing campaign may not be immediately visible, but they can still have a significant impact on a business’s performance over time.

The complexity of modern marketing means that it can be difficult to measure the effectiveness of individual tactics and campaigns accurately. Marketing involves a wide range of tactics and channels, and it can be challenging to isolate the impact of individual tactics on a business’s performance. This means that the results of a marketing campaign may not be immediately visible, but they can still have a significant impact on a business’s performance over time.

If you’re not looking at qualitative data, you’re not really measuring your marketing

Qualitative methods of measuring marketing effectiveness, such as customer satisfaction surveys and brand awareness studies, can provide valuable insights into the impact of marketing efforts. These methods differ from traditional, quantitative metrics like click-through rates and conversion rates in that they focus on collecting and analyzing subjective data, rather than quantifiable metrics.

Customer satisfaction surveys, for example, can provide valuable information about how customers perceive a business and its products or services. These surveys can help businesses identify areas for improvement and track changes in customer satisfaction over time.

Brand awareness studies, on the other hand, can provide information about how well a business’s marketing efforts are working to increase awareness of its brand. These studies can help businesses track changes in brand awareness over time and compare their performance to competitors.

In general, qualitative methods of measuring marketing effectiveness can provide a more comprehensive view of a marketing campaign’s impact. These methods can help businesses identify areas for improvement and track the long-term impact of their marketing efforts. Additionally, because these methods focus on subjective data, they can provide valuable insights into the customer experience and help businesses understand how their marketing efforts are perceived by their target audience.

Quantitative data can create the illusion of understanding

It’s tempting to push your business toward only those things that show up clearly and neatly on a spreadsheet. They feel more “real,” and it seems as though you can trust them without having to put much thought into it.

However, that simplicity of thought too often leads people to ignore large portions of the effectiveness of their marketing efforts, simply because they don’t add up nicely.

Marketing is about the long-term relationship you have with your customers, right? Well, think about your long-term interpersonal relationships. You might be able to summarize elements of them (“How many times did Tim text me last month?), but are those really an accurate representation of the relationship? Isn’t it possible that there’s more going on than you can reasonably squeeze into a column in Excel?

It’s the same with marketing. The fact that you can’t boil something easily down into a number doesn’t mean it’s not very real and very relevant to the success or failure of your business. Marketing is, by its very nature, both qualitative and quantitative, and any business that ignores half of that reality does so at its own peril.

Smart People Always Want to Mess This Up

Smart People Always Want to Mess This Up

Several weeks ago, my company released a new product: a tool that helps small service businesses with client follow-up. We did it very quietly, late one night after most of the department had gone home. A few of the product leaders made the decision, flipped the...

Five Pillars of Social Media Marketing

Five Pillars of Social Media Marketing

It's easy to get whipped up into the hype of social media marketing. Maybe you're just getting started with a new brand account, or maybe you've just been put in charge of all the company's existing followers. Either way, here are some basic principles that'll help...

Purpose-Driven Companies Make More Money

Purpose-Driven Companies Make More Money

“A real purpose can’t just be words on paper. It has to get under the skin of every member of your organization…. If you get it right, people will feel great about what they’re doing, clear about their goals, and excited to get to work every morning.”— Roy SpenceWhen...

What’s Your Company’s Internal Compass?

What’s Your Company’s Internal Compass?

One of the hardest questions we ask in our discovery workshops is also one of the simplest and most fundamental: “Why does your company exist?”You’d think most CEOs would have a ready (and passionate) response to that question, but most don’t. When asked that...

The 5 Key Customer Motivators

The 5 Key Customer Motivators

Far too many experiences are designed around the assumption that people want to be engaging with them. It’s an easy mistake to make. If you’re designing, say, an ecommerce site, it would be natural to assume your customers have an internal drive to find a product they...

Why Business Owners Fear Customer Research

Why Business Owners Fear Customer Research

Customer research is fundamental to the design process. It’s been well established that relying on assumptions alone leads us to make biased decisions that often fail to reflect the reality of the customer’s needs and wants, leading to poor results (including reduced...